I'm afraid I'm not much help - I usually use a SMALL piece of soft bread, wrap the pill in it and they gulp it down before they know what they're eating. It's less messy than peanut butter or cheese - and certainly less expensive than pill pockets. I usually start them off with a TINY bite of plain bread - then the pill wrapped in bread. Seems to work with all of mine. Some things I can get them to eat directly - (some of the flavored pills) - but normally the ol' pill in the bread trick works well for everyone in my pack.