Well, we had a breakthrough yesterday and I was so happy about it. We were at the local pond in the woods. Kim always swims and chases after balls and sticks in the water. Suddenly Noa joined in for the first time ever. She had such fun going into the water and bringing back sticks. She didn't dare swim but was in pretty deep. Now to stop her growling at other dogs! I don't think Noa is Einstein but she often looks deep in thought.